Skip to main navigation Skip to main content Skip to footer

SOAR user guidance for Appraisers

SOAR user guidance for Appraisers


This section details specific guidance for appraisers on using SOAR.

For other resources related to the appraiser role, please see the Resources for appraisers section.

Key appraiser tasks on SOAR:

  • Create appraisal interview (so that appraisee can submit and share documents)
  • Draft Form 4
  • Complete Form 6B feedback

How SOAR works (the appraisal process)

  1. Appraiser and appraisee agree meeting date/time/location outside of SOAR

  2. Appraiser creates interview meeting on SOAR

  3. Appraisee completes appraisal Forms 1-2 and 3 (this can be started any time throughout the year before interview is created)

  4. Appraisee submits completed forms and agrees to confidentiality statement

  5. Appraisal meeting takes place

  6. Appraiser drafts Form 4

  7. Appraiser forwards Form 4 to appraisee for review and sign off

  8. Process is completed whenever appraisee signs off Form 4

  9. Automated email confirmation sent thereafter

SOAR process overview
(click to open enlarged image in new window)

Creating an interview

First, agree a meeting date/time and location with the appraisee via phone / email etc (outside of SOAR).

  1. Login to SOAR (switch to "Appraiser" role)

  2. Click on Interviews from the menu

  3. Click on Create Interview button

  4. You will be prompted to select the appraisee from a dropdown list

  5. Enter meeting details

  6. Select Appraisal Period (April to March) of WHEN interview is scheduled (NOT what material is discussed - see below for clarification)

  7. Add any additional comments (if applicable)

  8. Finish by clicking on Save button

Please Note:

  • Creating the interview allows the appraisee to submit forms 1-3 for sharing with you
  • Appraisees CAN proceed to complete their appraisal forms without the interview being created; BUT until the interview is created, they have NO way to share the online forms with you
  • In some boards where resources allow, appraisal meetings are arranged by the Admin teams; if you are not sure who should be creating the interviews - please ask
  • Create an interview by creating a NEW interview, NOT by adding a new date to an old appraisal
  • Only add additional dates to an existing appraisal if more than one meeting was arranged to discuss matters further e.g. late MSF/PSQ submission etc (see below)
  • Can't select the correct appraisal period?  Chances are another appraisal already exists in the same period...  Check the appraisee's appraisal history and seek help from your local health board admin teams or the SOAR helpdesk as needed.

Adding more meeting dates to an interview

There will be occasions where more than one meeting is required for an appraisal, for example:

  • Additional meeting to discuss MSF/PSQ; 
  • Meeting got cancelled due to illness, etc

DO NOT create a new interview.

  1. Login to SOAR (in Appraiser role) and click on Interviews from the menu

  2. Search for interview; and click on corresponding notepad icon (don’t click on the appraisee's name as this takes you to their user profile instead)

  3. When you are in the meeting details page, click Add new meeting date button

  4. Enter details of new meeting

  5. Note reasons/purpose of new meeting in comments section as appropriate (e.g. new meeting to discuss MSF)

  6. Click Save to finish

Repeat to add more dates as required.

Alternatively, rather than adding a new meeting date as per step 4 above, you could overwrite the original meeting date/time instead.

Appraisal period explanation

Appraisal Period is used to log WHEN an interview took place in fiscal years (April to March) – rather than what materials were discussed.

This is to satisfy Revalidation requirements and allows us to track whether an appraisee has
been maintaining their annual appraisals.

We expect appraisal discussions to be centred around material within last 12 months/since
last appraisal.

For example:

  • If an interview took place on 12th March 2015, it would fall under the Appraisal Period of 2014/2015
  • If an interview took place on 8th April 2015, it would fall under the Appraisal Period of 2015/2016

Whilst a red text message will appear on SOAR prompting you if the selected appraisal period does not match the meeting date, you can overwrite/ignore this message in instances of late appraisals (typically in April/May time).  Check in with your local health board admin team in the first instance if you are unsure.

Appraisee wants changes made to Form 4

Making changes to Form 4

  • Only appraisers can create and edit Form 4 (for quality assurance purposes)
  • When forwarded to the appraisee, Form 4 is locked from further editing
  • To make changes, the appraisee needs to make a "Change Request"
  • This unlocks the Form 4, allowing the appraiser to edit as appropriate and re-forward

Form 4 – Change Request

  • Change Request has to be made by the appraisee
  • But they are only able to make a “Change Request” if Form 4 has been forwarded – if not, then it means the Form 4 is still with the appraiser for editing
  • If you (the appraiser) are still drafting Form 4, you will see the formatting toolbar in the comments boxes

When Form 4 is signed off, the appraisal is marked as completed and archived.  If the appraisee wants to make changes to Form 4 at this stage, a request needs to be sent to the Health Board Admin (or SOAR Helpdesk) for unlocking.

Appraisees will not be able to amend submitted appraisal forms 1-3 when the Form 4 has been signed off, but can add further documentation if required (e.g. MSF, PSQ etc) - but again it needs to be enabled by the admin team (see below).

Appraisee instructions are available in the Appraisees section.

Adding more documents after appraisal has been signed off

When an interview is completed, the submitted Forms 1-3 are archived; and the appraisee’s draft Form 3 is wiped to allow for the preparation of next appraisal (Forms 1 and 2 are not reset, but appraisees can amend details here if needed).

Because of this, it is NOT possible to amend submitted Forms 1-3 after interview has been completed - but further documents can be added if required.

This requires Form 4 to be unlocked via Health Board admins (or SOAR Helpdesk) and the "Additional Documentation" function enabled.

Once Form 4 has been unlocked and "Additional Documentation" is enabled:

  1. The appraisee navigates to Interview details page where there should now be an additional tab along the top - "Additional Documentation"

  2. Appraisees click Upload button to upload documents directly there

  3. When finished, appraisee can click the Notify Appraiser button, which triggers a system-automated email to the appraiser

  4. Appraisees will not be able to link documents uploaded in the draft forms

  5. Any documents uploaded directly here will be included in the PDF export of the submitted Forms 1-3 as well

  6. Appraiser reviews the submitted documents

  7. Tick the Seen by Appraiser tick box to date stamp (this lets the appraisee know you have reviewed the document)

  8. Amend Form 4 (if appropriate) and re-forward to appraisee for sign off

  9. When interview is signed off again, the newly added documents will also be archived to the appraisal

Create and Edit Form 5A (Exemption of Appraisal)

Form 5A is used in lieu of a Form 4 if the appraisee has a legitimate and valid reason for
exemption from appraisal in a particular appraisal year.  Reasons for exemption include:

  • Maternity leave
  • Sabbatical leave
  • Sick leave
  • Working abroad etc

To create a Form 5A:

  1. Create a new interview for the appraisee with a dummy interview date/time – Please see "Creating an Interview" above for reference

  2. When in Interview details, click on Create Form 5A button - this creates the Form 5A and you will automatically be taken there

  3. Select the name of the Appraisal Lead who will approve this Form 5A

  4. Select the reason for exemption from appraisal

  5. Select the date that the Appraisee left work and the date that they plan to return to work

  6. Add further comments if necessary

  7. Once completed, click button at bottom of page to forward to the selected Appraisal Lead for their review and sign off

  8. When Form 5A has been signed off by the Appraisal Lead, auto confirmation email is sent to appraisee, appraiser and Appraisal Lead

Please Note:

Appraisers should consult with their Appraisal Lead first before filling out this form.

NB: Form 5B is used to log anyone who fails to engage with the appraisal process.  Again, consult with Appraisal Lead in the first instance,

Enabling Autosave

As of mid-2018, a site-wide autosave function was introduced to all users.

By default, Autosave is disabled for all users.

But when enabled, it is triggered every 60 seconds, saving whatever form you were filling in.  If you altered your form and tried to leave the page before the autosave kicked in, you will be prompted to save the content of your form before leaving the page.

However, there are compatibility and performance issues (speed) for those using Internet Explorer as their web browser.

We appreciate that it is not always possible to change or upgrade the web browser you use, especially if you are in hospital offices or using GP practice computers. So to remedy this, we made the Autosave an opt-in function.

If you are using Internet Explorer and you experienced speed performance issues on SOAR, please consider using an alternative web browser first.  If not possible, then you can disable the Autosave.

As an appraiser, please consider (if possible) enabling the Autosave for the purposes of drafting Form 4s.

Autosave can be enabled / disabled by:

  1. Clicking on the Autosave icon/status message in the header (after you have logged in)
  2. This will take you to your profile setting
  3. Click and un/check the tickbox on screen
  4. Finish by clicking on the Save button

Completing Feedback Form 6

Feedback Form 6 is enabled after appraisal Form 4 is signed off by appraisee.  Appraiser completes Form 6B; appraisees complete Form 6A.

Form 6 appears as an additional tab along the top of the interview details page; and also as a reminder on the appraisal timeline function on the appraiser dashboard.  It will remain on the dashboard for 8 weeks and is hidden automatically thereafter.

For appraisers, the first ten Form 6B are used for benchmarking purposes; thereafter it is optional and the form is designed as a reflective tool with different questions set.

Accessing Feedback Form 6 report

The Form 6 feedback received is collated anonymously into a report which can be accessed via the Reports section from the menu on the left.

The report is anonymised and is designed to help you reflect on your practice in the appraiser role.

Prior to the report being generated, appraisers are asked to set a date parameter.  To ensure the process is anonymous, a report is only produced if the search criteria includes at least 3 results.

University co-appraiser is missing from interview details

This applies if your appraisee is a clinical academic.

If when you are creating the appraisal meeting and you notice that the university co-appraiser is not listed - find out from appraisee who the universoty colleague involved is, and liaise with your health board admin team ASAP to request:

  • Co-appraiser is assigned to the appraisee; AND
  • Co-appraiser is ADDED to the appraisal you created.

If appraisal is created before a co-appraiser is assigned, then they will need to be manually added to the appraisal so that they have access to the appraisal forms and be involved with the Form 4 sign off.

For more information about the joint appraisal process, please check guidance on Clinical Academics appraisal.

How to delete a duplicate appraisal

If a duplicate appraisal was created in error please liaise with either the health board admin team or the SOAR helpdesk to delete from the system.

SOAR is designed to handle only one appraisal at a time, duplicate appraisals will lead to appraisee submission confusion and also potentially cause issues in PDP section when signing off Form 4.



This page was last updated on: 28/01/2022